Beck Coolio From The Archives Guided By Voices Hole Johnny Cash Latest Liz Phair Music Neil Young Nine Inch Nails Nirvana Pavement Pazz & Jop R.E.M. Robert Christgau The Beastie Boys The Culture The Offspring Veruca Salt Warren G

1994 Pazz & Jop: Hegemonia Sez Who? Is the “Alternative Rock” Rule or the Role?

1994 Pazz & Jop: Hegemonia Sez Who? Is the “Alternative Rock” Rule or the Role?

21. or 22. The winner of the Pazz & Jop Standards voting is hardly smart, except maybe for many who have introduced the green little zoo's zeitgeist for the Green Small Band. Most of the intelligent young choices had Hole's Reside By way of undertaking that was 1 month ago and had little to do with their sex. One cause for Liz Phair's place as the first female winner in 19 years was so robust that it meant a change in rock sexual coverage, making Courtney Love's position as the second consecutive feminine winner on a relatively occasional foundation. His gender is an important a part of his attraction – at the core of what he says and the way he says it is essential to his offspring to the insanity of sexism. But it is not the headline news in the militaries where feminine artists can finally obtain everlasting respect. Zeitgeistwise, Love means bohemian – absolutely recognized by the subculture he fears, hears and provides himself each time he attracts a stage – earlier than he marks a lady. And he additionally means a widow before he makes a lady. Only I don't mean widows, I mean FOK, and perhaps FOK ought to come first.

I imply, we acquired Kurt's pals all over this survey. We obtained his spouse in his first situation, the fourth variety of his group, the quantity 5 of his Dutch uncle; we received his new good friend Michael Stipen again to seek out the guitar by three and his substitute love object by crossing Trent Reznor in 9 and Seattle's Soundgarden, who lived in career 11 and Seattle's Pearl Jam eyeballing in deaths 25. video listing with three of them. We've acquired a lot of "alternative" albums accredited and accepted by Pazz & Jop, which went to the multi-platform and didn't thoughts Gap Gold. Briefly, we obtained the Nevermind revolution, three years after Nirvana's massive debut was a software for the Amerindie aesthetic. The option not only performs a task, it guidelines; it is mass culture, mainstream, hegemonic. Leaving us not solely to the everlasting question "Alternative to what?" But for a brand new "Hegemonic Season which?"

Pazz & Jop & # 39; 94 is the victory of subculture and era at the most blatant degree. nationwide postpunk-bohemia, which has given our survey since the starting of the 80s, when all REM to Minutemen have been crucial bands. The fact that the victory is principally symbolic – not only limited to the universe of indicators, however to the try and quantify quality there – doesn’t invalidate its sweep. Talk about blitzkrieg bop. In 1994, Pazz & Jop's polite ecumenical mix of Euro and Afro, Yank and furriner, fart and fur was demolished. This was a black music breakthrough in Pazz & Jop history: six black artists among the prime 40, one in the prime 30 and the prime 20 being the smallest once we started counting right down to 40 in 1979; besides in 1978, when there were two zeros amongst the prime 20, the prime 30, they’re the least ever. The three albums of the British Isles additionally symbolize the lowest ever, only as soon as. Ambient Ethno's specialty, Malian guitarist Ali Farka Toure was the only "world music" finisher and certainly one of six black, and he wanted assist from Ry Cooder, one among the three surviving survivors. Additionally it is a document, and at the least half of the ringtones of Ry: together with his previous men, Neil “Forever” Young, whose postpunk affiliations are from 1979, and the primary black Johnny “Hard” Cash by Rick Rubin's modeled acoustic pseudocountry report influenced the younger mortals who have been fearful that the "real" gangsta may win them. As in the "real" world the place individuals buy their data, Money's help from Mavericks fans, Nashville's massaging of Nuevo Honky toners, with 35th place was an encouraging offensive, was at greatest random.

Don & # 39; don’t confuse you – just style, judgment about where music and culture was and was not in 1994, I go together with the electoral development. It was a terrific yr for a very good trendy guitar band. This was the first time since 1987 once I didn't make a hip-hop report or two of the greatest 10. Ditto for Afropop. In reality, my solely black voice was provided by the dance artist Heather Small on considered one of my two British albums Prime 40. M Individuals's Elegant Slumming got here informally with 55th voters, less than another report I gave; the other alternatives most critically in regular 10 reminiscence ended 1-2-4-10-18-20-21-27-43. My voting tour is Los Lobos, who spinoffs Latin Playboys, which I suppose to be forty; the mother-pop band, which is paradoxically named Sonic Youth, which I do know is their forty years previous; Bob Mould of Sugar, who retired to Austin's boho enclave at 34; and Iris DeMent, who in the 21st century makes a 35-year-old Pazz & Jop set with Victoria Williams, two chin-up-Southern aunts who stability younger and cash, although both are young sufficient to be their sister (and daughter). With the exception of sugar, all four of those artists have been Shoppers Guided by the forceful A-minus solely to drown me into a mature music command – how wealthy and right they heard the air as a waveform. However it was underneath the age of 30, like Beck and Hole and Sebadoh and Pavement, and above all Nirvana – as well as voter favorites like Soundgarden and Green Day and to some extent Pearl Jam and Beastie Boys – who most satisfied the historical past of my emotion. And in this respect I may need heard them another way than fans naturally born.

There isn’t any one to give up unpleasant feelings, I have all the time taken to ease angle Amerindieyn – ingrates might call it a dilatory until. During the final decade, postpunk has even produced such joy-intensive sub-limits as rap and Afropop, and has additionally hoped for bohemianism – to differentiate sub-cultures that may check new ways to do issues. But bohemians are stupid and deceived places. Again when my hair was halfway by way of my again and my Decrease East Aspect room value $ 45 a month, I was cheated by hippieville's insularity, suicide, privilege and half-market analysis. And post-punk era, I’ve been wont to ask: "Why so glum, chum" The causes of nihilism, which endure from younger nostril rings and weird hair, are heavy as younger as themselves and never just because nihilism is rarer than it has acquired – in inventive outputs and in personal relationships, each alternakids make room for appreciable kindness and hope, and their darkest moments come a musical power able to turning a unfavorable charge. Typically, nevertheless, polarity remains unchanged, leaving solely misery and rage, passivity and laziness, deliberate inconsistency and helpless sarcasm, naive cynicism and low cost despair. And regardless that it goes properly – like Nirvana or Beck particularly – it’s troublesome for anybody who has spent 30 years watching youngsters get their lives, not saying that there are more direct routes from A to B. . Duh.

Nevertheless, in November I felt extra simpatico. Partly it was coming with Kurt. I weigh late, when the crap was empty, I read a number of books that have been on the record once more, and obtained critical MTV with Unplugged whose music I had previously denied because the low power content material was the final will and testomony. However, like most reside albums, this isn’t a layoff and flat moments, it goes a great distance in the direction of creating Cobain's geniuses. Singing his opaque words as an alternative of throwing them, he tones his influence, and in addition the ladies of Nevermind and In Uteron – thus serving to well-adapted optimists like me, contribute not only to his pain however to the extraordinarily alienated one who feeds it. And by November it was not only a lifeless man that made me feel it. As McGovernik's electoral founder, I do not consider that a shift of a few proportion factors from the registered voters to the lever means a change of national character. But that doesn't mean it's not scary to take a look at journalists and pundits for self-fulfilling evaluation. It doesn’t mean that the lifelike consequences of the Republican takeover usually are not appalling for the People, who’re the least expensive. And that doesn’t mean that without Tom Foley's kicks, the unfavourable adverse nabots unfold to Capitol Hill – to not point out that way back we had given us rock and roll rolls – not take out the really marginal varieties, "alternative" rocks (and "alternative" newspapers.

So my November was as shitty as lots of Pazz & Joppers' April, a timing distinction that matches someone who has believed that rock and roll shouldn't be a religion – that in case your life is saved on a rock and roll, it might either be saved, or it wasn't simply you don't comprehend it yet. Kurt's suicide bothered me, nevertheless it didn't surprise me much, and the American company Liberal suicide was simply as superb to traumatize me to feel it as deep as my young buddies did. Instantly, all the anarchic, contradictory data that I already had in 1994 have been the most blatant rage of the scent. Out of the blue, Beck and Cobain's Loopy jokes, bitter marginalization and free dissociation made the perverse. All of the sudden all this angst and confusion and cynicism and despair felt part of my day by day life.

Amerindie residents underneath 35, who now type our largest voting group, are not often nervous about personal identification. Whereas some choices look back once they could possibly be described as being underneath 30, even beneath the age of 25, and for most modern rock critics, including on this traditionally hyperceptic, culturally Catholic journal – contradictory and anarchic guitars are the world. Many respondents delight or ruthlessly or with their obligation or determined to broaden their physical views, and few are so ignorant or illiberal that they by no means consent to the compound. However regardless of what hip hop and funk and jazz and r & b in addition to basic and pop and blues in addition to nation and dance and trance in addition to african and hispanic and asian (and lounge)? For 10 or 15 years, these critics have lived round golf equipment, outlets, and radio stations specializing in such bands, and are wanting far beyond the limitation of musical language, they doubt more than the mindset, the principle of belief that it can be adapted for any objective value expressing, what’s value satisfying – at the very least any which means or need that interests them.

I don't need to overestimate how slender this world is. Lots of the various identified voters – albeit from one another (and doubtless from their schools) that contain potential contradictions – would find their 40 greatest in a hopelessly pop, slick, unindie, and so on. Anyway, contradiction is the custom of the dinosaur period – cf. Neil Young, cf. Soundgarden, cf. even boss-cheating artist Jon Spencer – who will remain unnoticed in new singer-songwriters like Liz Phair and Kristin Hersh and to a lesser extent postmodern folkie beck and to a larger extent premodern folkie Johnny Money and to what extent do you need to calibrate the everlasting folkist Jeff Buckley songwriters like Freedy Johnston and Victoria Williams. As well as, when such finishers are industrialist 9 Inch Nails and rap-derived Beastie Boys and demo-Hawking magnetic fields and pop-ambient Portishead and violin engineer Lisa Germano and music therapist Okay. McCarty and gosh-jazzlike Soul Coughing, everybody uses guitar. no one made an actual guitar. So our record is so much totally different. Though Nine Inch Nails and Portishead are both techno-like, they are attacking as Archie Shepp, the other is soothing as MJQ. Although the sidewalk and Pearl Jam are both guitar-driven, as cool as rain, the other as ornamental as Mariah Carey. And while Michael Stipe and Courtney Love are each politically talking about FOK, one looks like a cup of coffee while the different needs the most cake.

So, OK, I'm truthful, proper? And keep in mind that I stated this was an ideal yr for arduous guitar zones. Nevertheless, the best of seven 12 – Hole, Pavement, REM, (certainly disconnected) Nirvana, led by Voices, Soundgarden and Green Day, Younger and Beck and 9 Inch Nails, this shut sonically and Fortunate sophomore Liz Phair just isn’t so distant (if You've misplaced the invoice, Johnson's uncle stands alone together with his unwhine and his guide ax) – someway seems too united. It is unique, nearsighted; it might't last, it gained't last, and though it exhibits us all (not simply Amerindie natives, however their mother and father' supporters) who have digged out rock-is-dead rumors as long as we will keep in mind (Do you consider 1969? ), I don't want it to final. I am happy that I am, how my favorite positioned, that & # 39; [19659003] is all the more purpose to suspect that the disagreement this yr, the consensus just isn’t solely nitpikoita, cited above, requests and specialized pleasures.

For newcomers, there’s a critic hype and a yr of fantasy. Directed by Voices: nerd concocts in low mild hooks in the basement, magically shifting to Michael J. Fox on stage. And hey, he's virtually previous, hardly beneath 35, and he's acquired an actual job. (I want to thank my fourth grader for educating someone who loves his job like Robert Pollard, who has greater goals. At the very least, Courtney limits his remedy to his personal youngster.) Then there’s the mainstream hypes: Massive Jawn, who exploits in collaboration with Mud Brothers in Outlaw Rap, revealed on a vinyl supply and Liz, excuse me for having hardly produced sufficient tracking as an alternative of being infallible. The least enthusiastic EP record of poll history is the future – the 1994 Pizzicato 5 album, mentioned by 15 EPs, would have been in Fifth yr 1993, ending lower than 140. There’s a 41-50 listing, the place the "option" continues to be used Iron Arms: Veruca Salt, American Music Club, Sonic Youth, L7, Pretenders, Richard Thompson, Jack Logan, Seal, Seefeel, Wu-Tang Clan. The 1987 Isisebringer, Sonic Youth (43), and Public Enemy (60th), an unwelcome scarcity of perennial breeders who developed their innovations in 1994 with precisely the similar wisdom, and voters whose new traditions have been previous and on the approach. makes them semioficial biz interns, chain-gang volunteers shoveling bands for buzz bins. And the collective inflation of Phair, Kristin Hersh, Luscious Jackson, Lisa Germano, and lesser-known Okay. McCarty suggests that, in fact, my non-feminine ears are a voter who considers gender solidarity (men and women) an appropriate substitute for a full-service policy. Stay Via This punk track feeling, screechy lyricism, and throughout voracity would have taken it the prime five if Kurt had given up music to turn out to be a drug agent. Nevertheless, I might point out that Courtney could possibly be one other direct winner who makes women who do not know a better concept twice about the danger of feminism. Liz Phair didn’t "sell away" the youngsters, but he definitely was "freaked out", as I stated earlier, so you need to marvel when the most horrifying Courtney's rather more annoying movie star destroys him, the fools' aid, who find their dangerous character and lust attention unclear when in truth, they’re a cleverly orchestrated aesthetic country. I don’t ask Courtneya dinner, however I'm rooted to him, as a result of I feel he’s sensible (and sexy), as a way to have an excellent document, not just once in a while timed excellent – a document that bounced around in my prime 12 together with 5 different guitar albums, the decline in larger as it in all probability deserved. One should admit that I have not utterly launched Hole from assist for suspected particular help. But it’s OK, truly – as a result of one among Nirvana's greatness was the spontaneous anti-xxism of its typical Joe apotheosis, it’s natural that the women of the Nirvana Revival obtain additional credit score for the women. Unfortunately, this does not assist me to hear their data. Notably with Hersh, breaking could be personal – I've by no means acquired Laura Nyro, but I give others a solution to her emotionality. Luscious Jackson nevertheless, I’m constructive that there's not rather a lot, as a result of I hope that it was, and so you are feeling positive that they will be rewarded for their (theoretical) funky agape, as Veruca Salt transferred to cynicism or calculation or something – what I heard, and would not that There are issues you possibly can hear in the end?

Considering the feelings of Veruca Salt in the materials that inspired water polo attacks and even meals fights in the Group, where you'd assume it was necessary issues to struggle over, I eased that the critics had enough fun selecting "Seether" number is 2 years behind the yr, Beck's "Loser ". At the bottom of the listing are the 40 greatest albums, which is all the time a sign of health – voters who are actively enjoying the ebook in their own lives. Seven of the prime ten, nevertheless, have been in top-40 albums, most since 1986. Even worse for pluralists, six of them turned 15 of the various albums, and only two didn't produce movies. Worse still, 5 rap singles have been the smallest since 1987, and only a type of who might loosely name three dance registers – Crystal Waters "100% Pure Love" – ​​may be referred to as a club document

these models are usually not everlasting , but they worry me. In the techno era, dance music has grow to be a DJ instrument whose hits not mechanically cross – you must look for many who might really feel considered one of Lester Bangs's seven work on mastermination, exoticism, and disposability. Something that appreciates a baseball ticket is known as hip hop, Touré unapologia (“Skills, Son”) speaks for itself. I’m a chauvinist sufficient to the east coast to get his help to a quantity designated aesthetic milestones; take into consideration re-Wu-Tangia, and despite the fact that I’m additionally specialised in, I might all the time hear the artwork Jerussa and Nasissa (with the proviso that Nas music is his rymmeissään). But the questions Touré hardly assume to ask are just as many other options as a thousand are contemplating beneath them. Why is someone outdoors of the hip hop group? Hasn't it failed to go away outsiders to care for the inventive mistake itself?

It’s true that the core audience of the albums of Illmatic and The Solar Rises feels financially self-supporting, and it is plain that hip plenty are historically justified to pay a small sum of money to outsiders – if not numerous African-American music lovers not fascinated by Jerun's delicate tragic strokes, definitely white joy seekers. As a result of the American apartheid rap prophets turned malignant so virulent, I’m not losing area for exceptions, racial separatism – deliberate or actual, energy or default – turns into more and more unavoidable in hip hop. It should not be revered by the impulse to provide too much stress to which it reacts. Nevertheless it should hassle with integrations – as a result of we don't like it, for positive, but in addition because it appears short-lived. It's not just that the unrelated fans, who are given an alternate, are more likely to move additional purist punches to the crowd – hip hop, which rejects pop music and pop photographs. There isn’t a assure that a larger black audience can be fed when someone becomes more confident and more readable. One thing that may be stated about Pazz & Jop's options, including suspicious ones, is that, as the heirs of the ruling culture, they understand how they make themselves readable. A hip hop funnel or someone else is perhaps sorry because it mixes the distance between Okay. McCarty and Lisa Germano, however the difference between the voice and the thoughts is getting wider than the inseparable real variations between Nas and Jerun

this is something. Pazz & Jop rewards readability – pop hooks, pop success – and it ought to be. In fact it’s aesthetics, lasting satisfaction that experienced listeners find of their data. And right, the floor meanings don't final as reliably as you hear. However in a method or one other, that is nonetheless pop music, and for most of us, sharing contacts strengthens and enriches its satisfaction. The late Nirvana Revolution produced a wide-ranging sale on a scale that was only a forecast in 1991. It sweeps one (or two) hits of platinum (or multi-level) wonders like Weezer and Offspring (two albums mention each). like Billboard 200, corresponding to Sebadoh and Voices. And whether it is horrible in self-respect, its landslides secured so many generals who would sweep away from the decrease edge than the Amerindie group. Even then, our voters would have been about 15 % of African People, as we name, as an alternative of 8 %, what we obtained back, we might have had a extra helpful overview of the nation's hip hop declarations. . My guess: baby gangsta Warren G still on prime, Wu-Tang finisher, Biggie Smalls properly 68, Public Enemy and Digables (and Jeru) holding if they’re lucky.

Generalization about blocks is hard – most For instance, African-American critics will not be hip-hop specialists (and lots of who don’t belief we vote more than the government). Nonetheless hit third – Bar / None's Area-Age Bachelor Pad, Esqui's 60's Mexican pop-mewzick orchestra. Esquivel is a wild-eyed kitchmeister whose vogue is a era – over 40-year-olds don't give him a attempt because he reminds them of their mother and father' hi-fi priest to drive them out of the room. The boss is previous the weak spot of the anticononial nostril, but his demography was a Bar / None mailing record that reaches a number of kids who might not see free re-authorization all yr spherical. Regardless of how good you’re in a used CD store, you’ll be able to only vote on the recordings you hear; A report like the world historic genius, corresponding to Louis Armstrong's field, made 34 votes as an alternative of 150, as a result of solely (wild guess) 60 respondents have been serviced with it. And never simply because the publicists are horrible with the huge flags – because many citizens only get the largest labels on the "alternative" product, if any. As rock historical past grows in every path, it’s the basic practitioner of younger individuals, and the massive corporations for which zines and native weekend certificates complement boutique advertising, which now enhances all emergency methods, are positive if they do worse issues – specialists are the superb chain flour. That is so tragic that someone who is so completely happy that you simply nonetheless consider in criticism. I want to assume that, as far as attainable, lots of the younger crimes found Slim Gaillard (eight votes, no evil consideration) fairly vintage. In contrast to Esquivel, he means being fun.

In fact, it assumes that the younger options need to develop into public. In truth, most of them can't be bothered, especially relating to modern artwork, which purists define, what happens when the Atlantic spreads to Matador and triumphists like low issues that purchase as an alternative of sound, Johnny Money, Tall Dwarfs or Anal Cunt. And for me on this scale, the islandness appears suspicious as properly, suicide. Hegemonic sez who? In a world the place individuals purchase their data, our earthquake landscapes are just a flourishing pop music culture. I hope – in its place Mr. Renée Crist (see "Fun things"), which is probably too open and typical – the options and the subculture they symbolize are intelligent sufficient to deliver out some feelings when the truism it might't take house as fact. My worry is that the style of power places kiboshi on any occasion when alternarock-Bohemia did not need to stop another unbiased enclave in the Balkanized America, where one citizen in the eighth now pays to the streets of a group affiliation. [19659003] This yr our national electoral remark is a wierd factor that, with a couple of notable exceptions, there was nothing – especially the choices that had a lot to say about Courtney's inadequate feminism, which is absolutely punk, and whether Minty Recent is in entrance of Geffe. The environment is that Washington is them, we are the various, and it is hoped that the twain will never meet, as a result of we now have now obtained a large enough piece that feeds us permanently. Not an entire pie, even music-Biz terms, not an actual hegemony, but we're not grasping. As has been stated, I feel this is deceptive. Since the right-hand agenda is as a lot cultural as economic, the reaction to all the '60s is believed to have made this completely satisfied country, direct attacks on the weirdas, which have been thought-about to be trendy hippies, are inevitable when Hippi is bought as Invoice & # 39; – If yesterday the alternarock ought to show extra embarrassed than it seems possible, our cake shrinks to pronto, and although alternarock had developed a strong infrastructure even before the huge boys started to throw money on it, the essential elements of that infrastructure at the moment are in peril – the radio, school loans, relatively human public providers and the entire center class leisure building on which slackerdom is predicated. However why cheat? which is not a part of their circulation – which I do not imply even more indie uncertainties, but hip hop, dance music, direct pop and increasingly typically canon, which ought to be understood earlier than it is rejected or reconfigured. It’s also morally weak.

I say this with full confidence that some ponder and others jeer, and I am sufficient of a Dutch uncle, who believes that the answers to both are healthy. We all the time want young jerks that pump vagueness, regardless of how 95% of them are ineffective. I have for many years now hurmioinut lo-fi names ideology – the concept that poorly deliberate data are aesthetically and spiritually superior to them, the place you’ll be able to hear the individual devices and make some phrases. One among my issues with Stay By way of That is truly that I think that it’ll shorten the sound of the Gap guitar – Courtney's track is lo-fi alone. And one in every of the reasons I really like MTV Unplugged in New York is that I hear Kurt's each murmur. However because it turned out, my three favourite 1994 albums use the lo-fi concept foolishly to undertake it. Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star reduce Soiled and Goo's modest gloss with a textured alert the place Sonic Youth is going and where they have been. Mellow Gold makes use of numerous totally different purity sounds to create a convincing neo-realistic surroundings for Beck's greatest recorded and greatest recorded tracks. And Latin Playboys – David Hidalgo, Louie Pérez, Mitchell Froom and Tchad Blake, whose great statements from Kiki discovered loyal, cautious, and very oversized products – are constructing dream music that reveals the ambient techno for a mind trip. Without contemplating content material or zeitgeist, I made Latin Playboys from my No. 1 as a result of it was the most lovely album I might have heard for years. Mutta separatistisena vuonna, kun tämä kansakunnan runsaasti muukalaisvihaa on heikentynyt kovimmillaan Kalifornian latinalaisamerikkalaisille, ehkä se on enemmän opetettavaa kuin luulin. Varmasti saavuttaa ja koskettaa jotakuta on yrityksen hype. Mutta kuten "vaihtoehtoinen rock", se ei ole kaikki se.

Prime 10 Albums of 1994

1. Reikä: Elää läpi (DGC)

2. Päällyste: kiertävä sade, kiertävä sade (Matador)

3. R.E.M .: Monster (Warner Bros.)

Four. Nirvana: MTV Unplugged New Yorkissa (DGC)

5. Neil Younger & Crazy Horse: Nukkuu enkeleillä (Reprise)

6. Liz Phair: Whip-Sensible (Matador)

7. Johnny Money: American Recordings (amerikkalainen)

8. Äänet ohjaavat: Bee Thousand (Scat)

9. Nine Inch Nails: Downward Spiral (Nothing / TVT / Interscope)

10. Beck: Mellow Gold (DGC)

Prime 10 singles of 1994

1. Beck: ”Loser” (DGC)

2. Verucan suola: ”Seether” (DGC)

3. Coolio: “Fantastic Voyage” (Tommy Boy)

Four. Warren G: “Säädä” (Violator / RAL)

5. Beastie Boys: ”Sabotage” (Grand Royal / Capitol)

6. R.E.M .: “Mikä on taajuus, Kenneth?” (Warner Bros.)

7. Päällyste: ”Leikkaa hiukset” (Matador)

eight. (Tie) Reikä: “Nukkeosat” (DGC)
Liz Phair: “Supernova” (Matador)

10. Jälkeläiset: ”Tule ulos ja leikkiä” (Epitaph)

– 28.2.1995 alkaen

Pazz & Jop -julkaisut ja tulokset löytyvät myös Robert Christgau-sivustosta. Hänen viimeisin kirja, Is It Nonetheless Good Yalle? Viime vuonna julkaistiin viisikymmentä vuotta rock-kritiikkiä, 1967–2017

(toiminto (d, s, id)
    var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName (s) [0];
if (d.getElementById (id)) returns;
js = d.createElement (s); = id;
    js.src = "//";
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore (js, fjs);

  (asiakirja, käsikirjoitus ',' facebook-jssdk '));